Author: Biru Panda
The portal is closed now.
You can feel it when you scroll: that vague hunger, that restless seeking that never quite satisfies. The apps open automatically under your thumb. The feeds refresh. The algorithm serves you content optimized for engagement, but somehow you’re emptier than when you started. Something is missing, something we once had but can barely remember.
In mystical terms, we might say the veil has thickened, the gateway has sealed. The internet still exists, humming with activity and noise, but the magic is gone. The portal through which we once accessed something wild and uncontained has closed, and we’re left pressing our hands against the glass, trying to remember what it felt like on the other side.

What the Portal Was
This portal I speak of is a liminal space where normal rules were temporarily suspended. It was the gap between creation and capture, that beautiful window when a space existed but hadn’t yet been colonized by commercial or institutional logic.
In the 1990s, writer and anarchist philosopher Hakim Bey described what he called “Temporary Autonomous Zones”: spaces that exist outside normal power structures, even if only briefly. These weren’t permanent revolutionary territories, but temporary gaps in the system where people could gather, create, and exist freely before the authorities even realized the space existed. The early internet was exactly this: pockets of digital wilderness where sovereignty belonged to individuals, where you could be anyone, where opportunity felt limitless because no one was asking you to be someone you weren’t.

2005-2010: The First Portal
The internet was rising then, spreading into everyone’s homes and pockets. Forums thrived. Early YouTube was a wild garden of 14-minute vlogs about nothing. Blogging meant actual writing, not SEO-optimized content mills. MySpace let you customize your profile with HTML, and nobody knew what would happen next. Facebook was still just for college students. Twitter was people shouting into the void without verified checkmarks or brand accounts.
This was the era of discovery, when platforms gave you tools and then stepped back to see what you’d build. The internet belonged to people because the companies hadn’t yet figured out how to extract every drop of value from your attention. You logged on because you wanted to, not because an algorithm was puppeteering your dopamine receptors.
2020-2021: The Second Portal
Then the world locked down, and suddenly everyone was online. Not by choice exactly, but by necessity and something unexpected happened. For a brief moment, the internet became vital again, genuinely social again. Discord servers exploded into existence. People started weird experimental projects. Creativity felt urgent and real because the normal world had paused, and digital space was all we had.
It was chaotic and raw and alive in ways the internet hadn’t felt in years. The platforms hadn’t yet figured out how to regulate this new flood of human activity. There was a window, maybe eighteen months, where the portal cracked open again.
And then it closed.

What Made the Portals Special
1. Systems Hadn’t Caught Up Yet
This was the crucial element. People were doing things faster than institutions could commodify them. The platform existed, people flooded in with raw creativity and genuine connection, and there was this beautiful lag before the analysts figured out how to extract value from it. Before “engagement metrics” and “conversion funnels” colonized the space.
In those portal moments, people were absolutely unique in their way of using the platform. Communities formed organically. Trends emerged from genuine shared experience. When something went viral, it was because people actually cared about it, not because a team of growth hackers had optimized it for maximum shareability.
Contrast that with now. A trend emerges, and within 48 hours, every brand account has jumped on it, attaching their CTA, mining authentic culture to monetize it. The spontaneity dies because everything becomes optimized. The space that was “ours” becomes commercialized, and people instinctively move on.
2. The Rules Were Being Written in Real Time
When no one knows what “good content” looks like yet, everyone’s experimenting. Early YouTube was people just filming whatever… Unedited, raw, sometimes pointless, but human. The shift from long-form articles to micro-content happened gradually, organically, as people discovered what worked in digital space.
Now? Hook in 3 seconds. Optimal video length for the algorithm. Open with a pattern interrupt. End with a CTA. Are these aren’t natural evolutions? They’re impositions that came later when systems caught up, when the people in suits realized they could engineer behavior.
3. Tools Belonged to Users, Not Owners
MySpace gave you HTML access to your profile. They gave users power without knowing what users would do with it. Early Twitter didn’t design the @ symbol or the hashtag… Users invented those, and Twitter eventually just formalized what was already organically happening. These platforms were gifts from their creators, not traps.
The platform creators had one major role: provide the space. How it was used, what communities it birthed, what dreams people followed – this wasn’t surveilled or controlled to the degree it is now. The creators were learning alongside the users what their creation could become. There was genuine wonder and surprise on both sides.
MySpace didn’t wake up one day and decide “we’re going to be the platform for rock bands to break into the mainstream”… That just happened, and they watched it unfold with the same amazement as everyone else.

Living In A Remnant We Can’t Recreate
I remember opening Instagram in 2016 and spending time there because I was genuinely interested in what I saw. My friends’ photos. Weird art accounts I’d discovered. Moments that felt real. I stayed because I wanted to, and I left when I was done.
Now I open Instagram and… I’m trapped. Not satisfied, but unable to leave. There’s nothing I particularly like, but the algorithm and optimization are forcing me to stay longer. The experience has fundamentally shifted from curiosity leading to satisfaction, to vague impulse leading to endless scroll leading to dissatisfaction but somehow I’m still there.
This raises a devastating question: Did genuine interaction end a long time ago, and are they now trying to replicate it through algorithm tuning and optimization? Are we just living in the remnant of something we can never recreate, yet we’re hell-bent on recreating still?
The platforms looked at the data from the “old internet” era and noticed that people spent 45 minutes per day on their platform when it was magical. And they asked the wrong question. Instead of asking “What made this magical?” they asked “How do we keep that number without the magic?”
So they built synthetic retention. Stealing your attention with FOMO mechanics, endless scroll, “you might like this” suggestions carefully calibrated to keep you in a state of fog-seeking but never quite finding. They hit the metrics without delivering the experience.
It’s like trying to recreate falling in love by injecting someone with oxytocin on a schedule. The chemical is there, but the meaning isn’t.
Compare that to the old approach. Every feature now is A/B tested before launch. Every interaction is designed to maximize time-on-platform. There’s a team of data scientists predicting how users will behave before users even get access. The platform isn’t discovering itself through use… It’s being optimized before it even reaches people.
The modern approach says: “We know exactly what we want you to do here, and we’ve designed every pixel to make you do it.”
The old approach said: “Here’s a thing. We don’t know what you’ll do with it. Show us.”
That uncertainty, that not-knowing, was the opening. The portal opened because no one was trying to control what came through it yet.

How Brands Ate the Internet
But perhaps nothing closed the portal faster than brands discovering these spaces.
When a community creates something like a joke, a format, a trend, it comes from shared experience and genuine cultural expression. The “Goblet of Fire” reel format emerges because readers actually love that moment, they have feelings about it, they’re communicating something real to each other.
Then brands arrive with their cargo cult version of it. They copy the form without understanding or caring about the meaning. They’re not part of the community, nope, they’re wearing the community’s skin to sell something.
A brand isn’t participating in Harry Potter discourse because they love the books or because they’re part of reader culture. They’re there because their social media manager got an alert that “Harry Potter trending ↑ 847%” and they need to hit their engagement KPIs this quarter. They’re not there to participate by any means, they’re there to extract.
This parasitic mimicry kills what it touches. Once brands flood a trend, the community abandons it because it no longer feels like theirs. Brands aren’t participating in culture – they consume the authenticity that communities create, excrete an ad, and move on to the next trend to devour.
Consider Pinterest. It was created as a digital equivalent of cutting pictures out of magazines and pinning them to your bedroom wall. Personal curation. Dreamy. Collecting inspiration for yourself. The inherent purpose was non-commercial… You weren’t pinning arts/clothes to buy them necessarily, you were pinning them to imagine, to feel something, to create an aesthetic world.
Then brands realized: “Wait, this is just a product catalog we don’t have to pay for.” They turned a space for dreaming into a sales funnel.
And they do this everywhere. They see human behavior and immediately ask: “How do we optimize this? How do we extract value from this?”
- People sharing music they love → Spotify pushing sponsored playlists
- People making silly videos → TikTok monetizing everything through the Creator Marketplace
- People sharing life moments → Instagram turning posts into shoppable content
- People having conversations → LinkedIn turning networking into “thought leadership” performance
The portal can’t stay open when every genuine human expression becomes a marketing opportunity within 48 hours.

What We’re Really Searching For
Maybe what we’re truly searching for is unoptimized space. Space where things can exist without purpose. Where you can just be, create, explore, wonder without someone measuring it, monetizing it, or turning it into a conversion metric.
The “portal” opens when there are spaces that have no economic purpose yet. The portal closes when capitalism figures out how to price wonder.
And perhaps that’s why these portals can only be temporary. Once something becomes popular enough to matter, it becomes valuable enough to optimize. And optimization is the closing of the portal.
The cycle seems to be: Beauty → Popularity → Value → Optimization → Death.
Each time the portal closes, it seems harder to open again because the systems get smarter about capturing value faster, users become more cynical and aware they’re being data-farmed, and authentic culture gets consumed more quickly. The life of wonder is getting shorter with each cycle.
We can see clearly what we’ve lost now. We remember what it felt like when spaces belonged to us. We’re haunted by the ghost of the unoptimized internet. We scroll through feeds that feel like graveyards of genuine connection, looking for something that no longer exists, kept there by mechanisms designed to simulate the engagement we once gave freely.
The old internet dreams of us, of what we were when we logged on because we wanted to, when we created without metrics, when we belonged to communities that weren’t being mined for data. It dreams of the moment before systems caught up, before every space was optimized, before wonder had a price tag.
And maybe the clearest sign that dream is over? More than half the internet is bots now. 51%. (Google it.)
The portal is closed now. But in remembering what it was, maybe we’re learning what to look for next time one opens. Maybe we’re learning to recognize the feeling of a space that hasn’t been colonized yet. Maybe we’re learning to protect it a little longer. Or maybe we’re just learning to grieve what we can never get back.

In Summary
What I call a portal is a liminal space that opens when three conditions align:
- Technology offers a new blank canvas (early social platforms, broadband adoption, pandemic-driven migration online).
- Corporations, algorithms, marketers haven’t yet arrived to codify and monetize it.
- People interact driven by intrinsic human motives — curiosity, connection, creativity — not extrinsic rewards (likes, fame, sales).
When the portal is open, the internet isn’t a tool or a marketplace. It’s a co-created space that’s unpredictable and sovereign.
Even I wasn’t clear what this ‘portal’ actually meant when I started writing. It was just vibes like Daniel Craig in Knives Out: ‘It makes no damn sense. Compels me, though.’ But if I couldn’t articulate it myself, why did I choose to write it at all? Maybe that’s one of the strange thrills of being a writer: taking something you can only feel and making it visible. Converting dreams and half-formed longings into words, into something real enough to be shared. Who said you write to explain exactly what you know, most times you write to discover what you’ve been feeling all along.
And sometimes, in the act of writing, the portal opens just a crack.

All image credits for this blog post (blog image/featured image) has been attributed to respective artists in Image Credits page.
Written by Biru Panda
Nexus Arcadia by Biru Panda

2 responses to “The Old Internet Dreams Of Us”
-
A clear understanding given in this article about the past and present internet.
-
True. Internet was a genuine and better place before capitalism ate it up. Good ol’days!
Recent Comments
That is really thought provoking and comforting at the same time
Wow ! Very deep ! And very different from what you usually write !
Indeed a very thoughtful one again
Password protected
The complexity of this view point is mind-blowing. The root of this complexity isn’t its incomprehensibility but one’s incapability to…
I always enjoy reading your versatile views and especially this time I literally loved the metaphorical aspect of human life…
This really made me think deeper this Flow state. Great writing!
It’s truly commendable and this resonates with all of us
Really unique concept and even better explanation 🤌
A beautifully reflective piece — it reminds us that depth cannot be faked, only earned through genuine experience. It’s a…
What matters at the end is awareness and honesty. In the end, it is but ego. Truly a wonderful piece…
This is a thoughtful and honest reflection that avoids blame and instead seeks understanding. I especially appreciate how you frame…
It’s a very remarkable piece ! Something very strong that i feel everyone needs to hear !
Nice insights
Always so informative !

Browse Categories
Recent Posts
-
Another Light on the Epic Of Mahabharata
From BlogsReading Time:
9 minutes1,790 words -
The Burden Of Continuity: The World That Would Not End
From BlogsReading Time:
8 minutes1,431 words -
Protected: How to Run a Country With Agenda to Brainwashing Ratio
From BlogsReading Time:
1 minute13 words -
The Human Animal, Our Counterpart
From BlogsReading Time:
4 minutes820 words -
The Disappearing Coin: The Origin of Analogy
From BlogsReading Time:
4 minutes784 words

Leave a Reply