Author: Biru Panda
For 2 years, I chased consistency like it was a religion.
I believed the promise Substack made to us writers: that if we wrote regularly, showed up weekly, and gave our best, we would grow. We would be seen. We would find our people.
So I did exactly that. Every single week. Once. Twice. Sometimes more. Almost a hundred posts. Each newsletter with care, structure, and purpose. Not throwaway content, but a multi-layered publication. These five sections didn’t all exist from the beginning, they developed slowly over time. In the early days, the structure varied, but it almost always included multiple parts. The current form -> Nerdy, Soul Snacks, Crossword, Local Orbit, and Updates came together gradually, as the newsletter evolved into its full shape:
- Nerdy: Tech, productivity, tools, and curious internet things
- Soul Snacks: Poetic reflections, philosophy, quotes
- Crossword: Wordplay, puzzles, original grids
- Local Orbit: Where I promote my creator friends
- Updates: Tools I discovered, apps I loved, things I made
And I was told: this is how you build a voice. This is how you grow.

But two years in, I looked around and saw what was actually growing.
Tiny posts. Shallow posts. 400-word image-heavy bursts of fluff. Posts titled “What I Bought This Week” getting 10,000 likes. Single-thought Notes going viral with no substance. And there I was, posting 5-section newsletters every week with less than a whisper from the platform that promised me discovery.
I reached out to Substack. They told me I wasn’t growing because my newsletter was “spread across too many genres.”
Imagine being told that your voice is too rich to be discoverable. LOL. That because you don’t flatten yourself into a box, you can’t be helped.
That your creativity, your very range, is what makes you unpromotable.
They told me to comment more. Use Notes more. Engage more. Basically, trade my time for attention tokens. Say “nice post” to other writers in the hope they’ll follow me back. Perform engagement like it’s theater.
Is that what this has come to?
A place for writers that rewards algorithmic mimicry over craft?

SEO Trap
I used to think popularity was a byproduct of quality. But I’ve learned that it’s not. It’s a product of strategy, not sincerity.
And when I tried to play that game, when I dabbled in SEO, I realized the truth:
SEO doesn’t amplify your voice. It dissolves it.
It tells you, “This is what people are searching for. Write like this. Use these words. Talk about these things.” And slowly, your edges get sanded down. Your strange becomes standard and your voice becomes theirs.
Most people don’t even realize what their own voice sounds like, because they never gave it a chance to emerge. From the very beginning, they’re told to study trends, match tones, stay relevant, write what’s performing. And so they mimic. They emulate. They chase.
They never discover their own creative DNA because they’re too busy twisting it into whatever the algorithm favors that week. And sure, they might grow. They might even win. But it’s not their win — it’s the algorithm’s. It’s a victory scored in someone else’s arena, by someone else’s rules.
You blend into the algorithm. You win at their game. But it’s not your win.
The game was always rigged.

But You Do All Genres?
A friend asked me recently:
“But if your newsletter has tech, poetry, games, and community -> why doesn’t Substack push you in all four lanes? You’re not genre-less. You’re genre-rich.”
Exactly.
Why not surface my work to people in each of those spaces? Why does multi-dimensionality get punished instead of celebrated?
Because Substack’s discovery is based on categorical simplicity. And anything that doesn’t fit neatly into one box is treated like noise.

Meme Pages Grow Faster
Let me be blunt: If I wanted fast growth, I could open a meme page tomorrow.
10 minutes a week:
- Scrape memes
- Generate captions with AI
- Repost trending content
- Comment on trending Substack Notes
- Say “let’s connect!” 20 times a day
Boom. Growth. Shallow. Effective. Effortless.
Meanwhile, real writers? Deep thinkers? They’re buried. Outwritten by templates. Outperformed by reposts.
And still, Substack has the audacity to pretend like it’s a platform for writers.

What Is Substack, Really?
At this point, I have to ask: What is Substack actually offering me?
If discovery doesn’t work for layered writers, If depth gets no visibility, If consistency means nothing, And if the only way to grow is to mimic the worst parts of social media,
Then why am I here?
What value does this platform bring?
Because right now, it feels like Substack is just a glorified email tool wrapped in the illusion of community. One that punishes originality, penalizes genre fluidity, and applauds shallowness because it’s easier to categorize.
If you’re reading this and feel it too and feeling the the bitterness, the fatigue, the sense of shouting into the void while fluff gets the spotlight, know this:
It’s not you. It’s the system. And the system was never built for multidimensional voices.
But we exist. And we write anyway. And we get to keep out voices.

All image credits for this blog post (blog image/featured image) has been attributed to respective artists in Image Credits page.
Written by Biru Panda
Nexus Arcadia by Biru Panda

Recent Comments
That is really thought provoking and comforting at the same time
Wow ! Very deep ! And very different from what you usually write !
Indeed a very thoughtful one again
Password protected
The complexity of this view point is mind-blowing. The root of this complexity isn’t its incomprehensibility but one’s incapability to…
I always enjoy reading your versatile views and especially this time I literally loved the metaphorical aspect of human life…
This really made me think deeper this Flow state. Great writing!
It’s truly commendable and this resonates with all of us
Really unique concept and even better explanation 🤌
A beautifully reflective piece — it reminds us that depth cannot be faked, only earned through genuine experience. It’s a…
What matters at the end is awareness and honesty. In the end, it is but ego. Truly a wonderful piece…
This is a thoughtful and honest reflection that avoids blame and instead seeks understanding. I especially appreciate how you frame…
It’s a very remarkable piece ! Something very strong that i feel everyone needs to hear !
Nice insights
Always so informative !

Browse Categories
Recent Posts
-
Another Light on the Epic Of Mahabharata
From BlogsReading Time:
9 minutes1,790 words -
The Burden Of Continuity: The World That Would Not End
From BlogsReading Time:
8 minutes1,431 words -
Protected: How to Run a Country With Agenda to Brainwashing Ratio
From BlogsReading Time:
1 minute13 words -
The Human Animal, Our Counterpart
From BlogsReading Time:
4 minutes820 words -
The Disappearing Coin: The Origin of Analogy
From BlogsReading Time:
4 minutes784 words

Leave a Reply